Mlp Daring Don't Review

3 min read

Deviation Actions

byter75's avatar
By
Published:
4K Views

Daring don’t I deem a drudgery.

This episode seems to have an identity issue. The semblance of simple minded action story is there, much like the Indiana Jones’ movies it takes inspiration from, but this episode has a critical issue with who it focuses on and the story it tries to tell.

Indiana is always the protagonist of his own movies, because everything revolves around him, the story and action is from his perspective or built around him. Daring don’t has the story and acton revolve about Daring Doo, but has Rainbow Dash be the main character.

It wants to tell both a simple fun action story, but also it want to tell a story about a fangirl’s self importance issues. The two types of story are oddly meshed together, with Dash (and rest of the M6) acting as just observers to the main story almost all the way until the end. It makes our protagonist a supporting character to her own story.

Rainbow Dash’s fangirl angle is pushed really hard this episode. It’s a flanderization of her character and makes her come across as a bit of a 5 year old. This combined with her little involvement in the actual plot, reduces the impact of her arc.

Also, speaking of the actual main character, Daring Doo being an actual person really strains my suspension of disbelief and she seems to be just the awesome action hero of her stories. She is shown as being without fault or risk; She hurts her leg but that’s forgotten, she gets captured but that was her plan all along and she’s so competent and independent. Her main fault seems to be that she is a jerk but that is for her own reasons (but keeping secrets when you publish all your adventures is kinda contradictory). Which all in all, makes Daring Doo not much of an interesting or deep character, which also hurts my engagement in her main story.

I was surprised to hear this was another Dave Polsky episode, because this story doesn't have much of his crude humour that usually undermines everything, it actually is just a lot of talking and action which is an improvement I guess. The story doesn't fit that well together though. The meaning in RD’s fangirl breakdown is undermined by the more action oriented story it’s built around and that main action story isn't that great either. It tries to do two things at once and fails at both, it makes the whole thing pretty forgettable.
© 2013 - 2024 byter75
Comments34
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
The fangirl plot and the action plot are plots A and B in this story. The B plot isn't so much important, as it's a spin on the lesson learned in Applebuck Season (character is too stubborn to get some help, but learns how to put her trust into someone else). The A plot about Dash's confidence issues shines pretty well imo. We've seen her have issues keeping her fangirling under control (Best Night Ever) and we've seen that her self-esteem issues can hurt her judgement and performance (Sonic Rainboom). This episode decides to throw all of that back at Rainbow, but with her other idol, Daring Do. Why DD? If we did this story with the Wonderbolts again, it would feel like a step backwards, as Rainbow has shown to be confident around them in Wonderbolts Academy. So, this is at least logical.

I'll concede that most of the main cast didn't need to be here. The reason they are is for support in the final confrontation, but besides that they have no place (Rarity and Fluttershy especially). Twilight made sense, as she both knows about the Daring Do series and therefore can help, and she acts as a foil to Rainbow's fangirling.

As for the concept itself, I'm chocking that up to Dave Polsky being the writer. He's always had bizarre episodes, and this concept is pretty out there. At the very least, nothing really said that Daring Do couldn't be a real pony; everyone (Twilight and Rainbow included) just assumed that she was fictional. I kind of thought they were going to do something like this, but it's still a weird concept. Not a deal breaker, but still weird.